Parenting styles vary across cultures, and the way children are raised can significantly differ depending on societal norms and values. Filipino and Canadian parents, although both deeply committed to their children’s well-being, have distinct approaches to discipline, shaped by their cultural backgrounds and societal influences. Understanding these differences can help improve cross-cultural communication and parenting effectiveness for Filipino families living in Canada or considering the shift in parenting styles as their children grow up.
What Are the Main Differences in Discipline?
Discipline is about teaching children right from wrong and helping them understand the consequences of their actions. While both Filipino and Canadian parents aim to raise responsible, respectful children, the methods of discipline differ in their approach, tone, and cultural expectations.
- Filipino Parenting Style: Filipino parents tend to adopt a more authoritative or authoritarian approach to discipline. They emphasize respect for authority, obedience, and the importance of maintaining family honor. Physical punishment, such as spanking, is not uncommon, though there is increasing awareness against such practices in contemporary Filipino parenting. Filipino parents may also use emotional reasoning, such as guilt or shame, to instill lessons in children.
- Canadian Parenting Style: Canadian parents, especially in the more liberal and progressive areas, tend to favor a democratic or permissive approach to discipline. This means encouraging open dialogue with children, explaining the reasons behind rules, and allowing them to express their feelings. Corporal punishment is not generally accepted in Canada, and many Canadian parents rely on time-outs, natural consequences, or positive reinforcement for teaching children discipline. There is a significant focus on child autonomy and ensuring children have a voice in family decisions.
How Do Filipino Parents Handle Discipline?
Filipino parents often prioritize respect, family unity, and malasakit (compassion) when disciplining their children. Discipline is often seen as a means of upholding family values and honor. The methods of discipline can vary depending on the family, but these are some common approaches:
- Direct Commands and Clear Expectations: Filipino parents are known to be more directive in their approach. Parents often give clear and direct commands, expecting children to follow them without question. This can stem from the cultural emphasis on respect for authority figures, such as elders and parents.
- Use of Emotional Appeals: Filipino parents frequently use guilt as a tool for discipline. For example, they might say things like, “How can you do this to me after everything I’ve sacrificed for you?” This emotional appeal is meant to make the child realize their actions’ impact on their parents and the family.
- Physical Discipline: Although less common in modern Filipino households, physical punishment (spanking or pinching) was historically used as a disciplinary measure. Today, this is often being replaced by verbal scolding or grounding, but cultural attitudes toward physical punishment can still persist in some areas.
- Emphasis on Family Honor: In Filipino culture, discipline is often tied to the concept of maintaining family honor or “utang na loob” (debt of gratitude). Parents expect their children to act in ways that uphold the family’s reputation, particularly in terms of respect for elders and proper behavior in public.
How Do Canadian Parents Handle Discipline?
Canadian parents generally prioritize fostering an open, respectful, and empathetic relationship with their children. Their goal is to help children understand the consequences of their actions without resorting to harsh or punitive measures. Some common strategies include:
- Open Communication: Canadian parents value conversations with their children about their actions and the reasons behind rules. Instead of dictating commands, they try to explain why certain behaviors are unacceptable and what could happen as a result. For example, rather than simply saying “no,” they might explain why a certain behavior is unsafe or unkind.
- Natural Consequences: Instead of imposing artificial punishments, Canadian parents often allow children to experience the natural consequences of their actions. For instance, if a child refuses to wear a jacket on a cold day, they may get cold and learn from that experience without being scolded.
- Time-Outs and Positive Reinforcement: Canadian parents often use time-outs to help children calm down and reflect on their actions. Positive reinforcement, such as praising good behavior or rewarding responsible actions, is also a key component of Canadian discipline strategies. The emphasis is on reinforcing good behavior rather than punishing bad behavior.
- Non-Physical Methods: While some Canadian parents may resort to mild forms of discipline, physical punishment is generally discouraged and, in some provinces, even banned in public schools. Canadian society places a high value on the emotional well-being of children, so many parents focus on non-violent ways of guiding their children.
Where Do These Differences Matter Most?
Understanding these differences in discipline becomes particularly important in the context of Filipino parents raising their children in Canada. The shift from a more authoritarian Filipino parenting style to a more permissive Canadian approach can create challenges, especially if the parents are trying to blend both cultural influences in their parenting methods.
- School Environment: Filipino children raised with more authoritative discipline may find the Canadian school environment to be more relaxed and open. Teachers in Canada typically encourage children to express themselves and make their own decisions, which can feel unfamiliar to children raised with stricter parental control.
- Peer Relationships: In Canadian society, peer relationships are often nurtured through mutual respect and understanding, with an emphasis on individual rights and autonomy. Filipino children, however, may find it difficult to assert themselves or speak up, especially if they’ve been raised to avoid confrontation or “disrespect” in their family dynamics.
- Parenting in Canada: For Filipino parents, adjusting to Canadian parenting styles can sometimes lead to confusion or frustration. Some parents may worry that the more relaxed Canadian discipline approach leads to children becoming disrespectful or too independent. This can be especially true if the child shows resistance to authority, as this is often perceived as disobedience in Filipino culture.
When Does the Conflict Arise?
The conflict between Filipino and Canadian parenting styles tends to arise during the adolescence years when children start questioning authority and becoming more independent. In Filipino culture, obedience is highly valued, but Canadian society often encourages children to speak up, express their individuality, and question authority.
For Filipino parents, the challenge lies in finding a balance between respecting Canadian values and maintaining Filipino traditions of obedience and family hierarchy. The when of this shift is important because it’s often during the teenage years that children begin to resist strict disciplinary measures, and parents need to adapt their methods to avoid conflict.
Why Is It Important to Understand These Differences?
Understanding the differences between Filipino and Canadian parenting styles is essential for parents, especially if they are raising their children in Canada or plan to do so in the future. Recognizing these differences can help prevent misunderstandings and allow Filipino parents to navigate the challenges of adjusting their discipline strategies in a new cultural context.
By blending the strengths of both styles—Filipino discipline’s emphasis on respect and family loyalty, and Canadian discipline’s focus on communication, autonomy, and empathy—parents can raise children who are both respectful and independent, balanced between their cultural heritage and the values of their new home.
Conclusion
Filipino and Canadian parenting styles reflect the unique cultural values of each society. While both prioritize love and care for children, their approaches to discipline are rooted in different traditions. For Filipino parents adjusting to life in Canada, it’s important to understand and embrace these differences to find a parenting style that works best for their family. By fostering open communication and a deeper understanding of cultural expectations, Filipino parents can raise children who thrive in both their cultural heritage and the Canadian context.
Pinoy Life In Canada Blog 
Leave a comment